Platform-Independent Experiments on Social Media

November 27, 2025  ·   Commentary

Two of our core faculty, Joshua Tucker and Jenny Allen, recently published a perspectives piece in Science in response to the recently published article, "Reranking partisan animosity in algorithmic social media feeds alters affective polarization."

Three people on phones and computers with reactions.

Credit: Adobe Stock

Social media is an important source of political information, yet there is little external oversight of platforms’ ever-changing algorithms and policies. This opacity presents a major problem: Conducting a real-world experiment on the causal effects of platform features generally requires the collaboration of the platform being studied, which rarely happens, and even when it does, future platform changes may invalidate prior findings. On page 903 of this issue, Piccardi et al. report one possible solution to this challenge. The authors introduce a methodological paradigm for testing the effect of social media on partisan animosity without platform collaboration by reranking users’ existing feeds using large language models (LLMs) and a browser extension. They find that changing the visibility of polarizing content can influence people’s feelings about opposing partisans.

Read the full article here.